Robin van Persie's late penalty earned Manchester United a fortunate 2-1 victory against 10-man Liverpool in an emotionally-charged Premier League clash at Anfield on Sunday.
The prolific Dutchman sealed the victory when he fired his spot kick past the despairing dive of Pepe Reina after Glen Johnson had brought down Antonio Valencia.
Despite being well below their best United moved into second spot with 12 points, one point behind leaders Chelsea.
The first match at Anfield since the Hillsborough report cleared Liverpool's fans of blame for the deaths of 96 of their number at the 1989 FA Cup semi-final, sparked into life after 39 minutes when Jonjo Shelvey was red-carded for a dangerous lunge.
However, the home side deservedly went ahead straight after halftime through Steven Gerrard's volley.
United hit back after 51 minutes through Rafael's curler before Van Persie's late strike meant that after five games Liverpool are still looking for their first league win of the season -- their worst start to a Premier League campaign.
"The last three or four years we have come and played better but not got anything, that is the way it goes sometimes," United skipper Ryan Giggs told Sky Sports.
"Liverpool wanted to put on a performance because of the occasion and they did that. They played well, but we can play better."
One of the fiercest rivalries in world soccer was briefly put to one side before kickoff as players and fans from both clubs respectfully marked a tribute to those killed in the Hillsborough tragedy.
An independent report published this month revealed that the disaster was caused by a breakdown in crowd management and was later the subject of a police attempt to pin the blame for the horrific crush on Liverpool's fans.
The crowd held up white and red cards spelling out "TRUTH" and "JUSTICE" as the players walked out on to the pitch in tracksuits emblazoned on the back with 96.
Opposing captains Gerrard and Giggs released 96 balloons into the Merseyside sky and the anthem "You'll Never Walk Alone" reverberated around the stadium with added emotion.
Even the race row between Luis Suarez and Patrice Evra was finally put to bed as they shook hands before kickoff.
Once the whistle went, however, it was Liverpool who settled down quicker, controlling the much of the first period.
Gerrard went close to giving them the lead and Fabio Borini should have done better with a half chance.
The first flashpoint came after 39 minutes when Liverpool's impressive young midfielder Shelvey lunged in feet first in a 50-50 tackle with Jonny Evans and was shown a red card.
He then gesticulated angrily at Alex Ferguson as he left the pitch, souring the mood of goodwill that had existed hitherto.
Shelvey's red card looked like turning the match in United's favour but instead it was Liverpool who took the lead a minute into the second period.
United again looked half asleep as Johnson surged into the area and when the ball looped up to Gerrard the England skipper had time to slam a precise left-footed volley past Anders Lindegaard.
It sparked wild celebrations around Anfield but they were soon silenced when Rafael equalised six minutes later, curling a shot beyond the reach of Reina from a tight angle.
Making their extra man count, United began to enjoy more possession although Liverpool, despite being down to 10 men, continued to show the greater hunger.
Suarez blasted one shot across the face of goal as Liverpool remained on top. Sensing an unlikely win they continued pushing men forward but when Valencia seized possession in his own half he set off on a blistering run that was ended by the desperate lunge of Johnson.
Van Persie, who missed from the spot earlier this seasonm for United, had to wait four minutes as Daniel Agger received treatment but he kept his cool to send a left-footed effort into the corner despite Reina almost clawing it away.
- Supporters hold up a banner in memory of victims of the Hillsborough disaster. Photo: REUTERS
- Bobby Charlton (L) and Ian Rush pose for photographers with 96 red roses in memory of the Hillsborough disaster. Photo: REUTERS
- Liverpool and Manchester United players shake hands. Photo: REUTERS
- Luis Suarez and Patrice Evra finally shook hands Photo: Getty
- Liverpool's Steven Gerrard (not seen) scores. Photo: REUTERS
- Liverpool's Steven Gerrard (R) celebrates scoring with team mate Martin Kelly. Photo: REUTERS
- Steven Gerrard celebrates scoring against Manchester United. Photo: REUTERS
- Steven Gerrard (L) challenges Manchester United's Shinji Kagawa. Photo: REUTERS
- Manchester United's Rafael (2nd R) watches Liverpool's goalkeeper Pepe Reina fail to save his shot. Photo: REUTERS
- Manchester United's Rafael (C) celebrates his goal with teammate Robin Van Persie (R) as Liverpool's goalkeeper Pepe Reina walks past; Photo: REUTERS
- Manchester United's Rafael (L) celebrates his goal with teammates Photo: REUTERS
- Patrice Evra did not have any incident with Uruguayan striker Luis Suarez during the game. Photo: REUTERS
- Liverpool's Luis Suarez (L) is challenged by Manchester United's Rio Ferdinand during their English Premier League soccer match at Anfield in Liverpool, northern England September 23, 2012. REUTERS/Phil Noble (BRITAIN - Tags: SPORT SOCCER). FOR EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NOT FOR SALE FOR MARKETING OR ADVERTISING CAMPAIGNS. EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR 'LIVE' SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 45 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS Photo: REUTERS
- Manchester United's manager Alex Ferguson gives instructions. Photo: REUTERS
- Robin van Persie scores on a penalty kick to give Man United the win. Photo: Getty
- the Dutchman celebrates. Photo: Getty